Mayor’s Cruise Ship Ban Blocked In Court

Nearly two weeks after Nice’s mayor Christian Estrosi attempted to expel Voyager of the Seas from the Villefranche-sur-Mer harbour, a French administrative court has blocked the local restrictions he tried to impose.

Mayor Estrosi Shouts At Voyager of the Seas

The dramatic standoff, which saw Estrosi approach the Royal Caribbean ship by boat to hand-deliver a last-minute order to the captain, has now been undercut by a legal ruling stating the mayor overstepped his authority.

On Sunday 13th July 2025, the court ruled in favour of Prefect Laurent Hottiaux, suspending Estrosi’s 9th July order that aimed to ban large cruise ships from Nice and strictly cap visits to Villefranche-sur-Mer.

“Only the prefect of the Alpes-Maritimes can, as part of his water police powers, organize the entrances, exits, and movement of ships,”

Court statement

Estrosi’s order would have barred ships carrying more than 450 passengers from docking at Nice and limited Villefranche-sur-Mer to 65 large ship visits per year, with no more than one per day.

National vs. Local Jurisdiction

While the mayor has argued that the limits are essential for environmental protection, sustainable tourism, and heritage preservation, the court found his unilateral actions “tainted with several illegalities” and a potential violation of public and individual freedoms.

The suspended order would have immediately affected five cruise calls to Nice in 2025 and 15 in 2026, from a total of 176 scheduled visits. For Villefranche-sur-Mer, the restrictions could have disrupted 12 calls this year and 53 more in 2026, affecting over 200,000 cruise passengers.

Reacting to the court’s ruling, Estrosi said the French government must now “assume its responsibilities” if local authorities are not permitted to regulate cruise visits independently.

The Voyager Incident

The legal case follows a tense confrontation on 3rd July 2025, when Voyager of the Seas anchored near Villefranche-sur-Mer.

Estrosi boarded a port police vessel and approached the ship, attempting to present his newly signed order to the captain.

However, in keeping with maritime law, the captain refused to accept the mayor aboard, as he lacked the appropriate credentials or authority to board the vessel during active operations.

Footage of the incident quickly circulated online, sparking criticism from cruise industry advocates and local officials alike.

“Access to ships in operation is strictly limited to registered passengers and crew members, visitors with pre-approval, and officials with proper authority,”

Philomène Bouchon, CLIA’s Director of Strategic Communications.

The Cruise Lines International Association (CLIA) also released a formal statement denying that any actual cruise ban had been put in place, emphasizing that Voyager of the Seas had been properly authorised by the very metropolitan authority chaired by Estrosi himself.

Bouchon called the mayor’s stunt “deeply regrettable” and warned it could damage cooperation efforts on sustainable tourism.

Cruise Calls Continue

With the mayor’s order now suspended, cruise operations continue as planned at both Nice and Villefranche-sur-Mer.

On Bastille Day, Celebrity Equinox and Queen Victoria both made scheduled calls to the Côte d’Azur, with several more visits on the horizon, including Explora II, Marella Discovery, Silver Whisper, and Celebrity Ascent through August.

It remains to be seen whether Mayor Estrosi will appeal the ruling or seek national legislative backing to reintroduce stricter cruise limits in the future.

For now, however, the court’s intervention ensures normal port access continues for the region’s summer cruise season.

TODAY’S BEST CRUISE DEALS!

Don’t miss these offers…

If you found this interesting, please share!

Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.