Guests sailing aboard P&O Cruises’ flagship, Iona, experienced a brief scare on 29th August 2025, when a small galley fire disrupted dining services and prompted a swift crew response.
The incident occurred while the ship was at sea returning to Southampton at the end of her 7-night Norwegian Fjords itinerary.
Passengers reported hearing an announcement calling for a first aid team to respond to a “fat fryer oil fire” on Deck 5.
Within minutes, more crew were summoned and team members were ordered to muster stations as a precaution.
Guests, however, were never instructed to leave their cabins or public areas.
The all-clear came after about 15 minutes, though several restaurants were closed, including the Pearl and Coral dining rooms on Deck 6.
Passengers near the affected area described corridors filled with the smell of burning oil and fire crews rushing through the hallways.
While the scene was unsettling, no injuries were reported and the crew earned praise for their quick and professional response.
Clean-up teams moved in immediately, limiting the impact to dining operations only.
Fire at sea is one of the most serious emergencies a cruise ship can face.
Well-trained onboard fire teams respond rapidly, while other crew prepare for possible evacuations.
Temporary restaurant closures are a standard safety measure to secure and ventilate the area.
Iona, which carries more than 5,200 guests and 1,800 crew, is expected to arrive in Southampton on schedule, ready to embark her next round of passengers.
Cruise Fires Are Rare
Fires onboard cruise ships are rare, and are typically dealt with by crew quickly.
A similar incident did occur earlier in the summer on the MSC Cruises ship MSC Orchestra, when an electrical switchboard caught fire.
The ship did lose power for a few hours as a result, but due to the quick action of crew members there was never any risk to the safety of the passengers onboard.
Another small fire broke out onboard the Princess Cruises ship Island Princess in July 2025.
Again this was quickly contained, although it didn’t stop several fake stories spreading on social media about an explosion onboard as passengers “feared for their lives”.
Always be careful what you read on social media when it comes to cruise emergencies, and check across several reputable cruise sources if you have any concerns that a story could be fake!
NEW DEALS JUST RELEASED!
Don’t miss the latest P&O Cruises offers…
Related Posts
If you found this interesting, please share!
Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.
Royal Caribbean is rolling out new benefits for guests who purchase The Key, its exclusive VIP add-on programme. The package already included popular extras such as priority boarding, carry-on luggage…
Guests aboard Disney Wish experienced a frightening evening on Tuesday 26th August 2025, when the ship’s “man overboard” alarm sounded shortly after leaving Nassau. Rescue operations were quickly launched, but…
A family holiday aboard Norwegian Getaway turned into tragedy when a father drowned at Bermuda’s Horseshoe Bay – and now his relatives are taking Norwegian Cruise Line to court. The…
Royal Caribbean’s ambitious new private destination, Perfect Day Mexico, has run into controversy as residents and activists raise concerns about the development’s potential impact on Costa Maya. A Change.org petition…
The oldest Carnival ship still sailing is Carnival Sunshine, which entered service in 1996 as Carnival Destiny and was rebuilt and renamed in 2013. Next come the two remaining Fantasy-class ships, Carnival Elation and Carnival Paradise (both 1998). Older does not automatically mean worse: these ships tend to offer shorter, cheaper cruises from convenient home ports, while the newest Excel-class ships add bigger attractions, more dining and more crowds.
This guide looks at the oldest Carnival ship line-up as of November 2026, what the older ships do well, what the newer ones add, and how to pick between them. If you just want the full fleet list in date order, see our complete list of Carnival ships from newest to oldest.
The Oldest Carnival Ship Still Sailing (and the Rest of the Veterans)
Carnival has not retired a ship since Carnival Ecstasy left the fleet in late 2022, and at the time of writing no further retirements have been announced. That leaves a group of ships that are 20 to 30 years old but still very much in service. Here are the oldest Carnival cruise ships sailing today:
Ship
Entered service
Original name / history
Where it sails (at the time of writing)
Carnival Sunshine
1996
Built as Carnival Destiny; rebuilt and renamed in 2013
Norfolk until May 2027, then Galveston from November 2027
Carnival Elation
1998
Fantasy class, original name
Jacksonville, 4- to 6-night Bahamas cruises
Carnival Paradise
1998
Fantasy class, original name
Tampa, 4- to 6-night Caribbean cruises
Carnival Sunrise
1999
Built as Carnival Triumph; rebuilt and renamed in 2019
Short Caribbean and Bahamas cruises
Carnival Radiance
2000
Built as Carnival Victory; rebuilt and renamed in 2021
Short cruises, including Mexican Riviera and Baja
Carnival Adventure
2001
Built as Golden Princess; later P&O Australia’s Pacific Adventure
Sydney, joined Carnival in 2025
Carnival Spirit
2001
Spirit class, original name
Moving to Tampa for 2027-28
Carnival Encounter
2002
Built as Star Princess; later P&O Australia’s Pacific Encounter
Brisbane, joined Carnival in 2025
A few points worth knowing:
Sunshine is staying. When Carnival announced that Carnival Freedom would take over Norfolk in 2027, many cruisers assumed Sunshine was leaving. Instead, Carnival confirmed she will move to Galveston from November 2027 with 4- to 10-day Caribbean and Mexico sailings, after a dry dock scheduled for late 2027.
Only two Fantasy-class ships are left. Carnival’s original eight-ship Fantasy class has shrunk to Elation and Paradise. Both are scheduled to keep sailing through at least spring 2028, with dry docks planned for Paradise in early 2027 and Elation in early 2028.
Adventure and Encounter are older than they look. The two former P&O Cruises Australia ships came to Carnival in March 2025 when that brand closed. They are Grand-class ships built for Princess in the early 2000s, so they belong with the veterans even though they are new to Carnival.
Venezia and Firenze are not old ships. Carnival Venezia (2019) and Carnival Firenze (2020) were built for Costa and moved to Carnival under the “Carnival Fun Italian Style” banner. They are among the younger ships in the fleet.
Ship ages change every year, but as a rule of thumb anything built before 2005 counts as an older Carnival ship.
Older Carnival ships often sail shorter, cheaper itineraries that suit families and first-timers. Photo: Tamar Kakhailishi on Pexels
What Older Carnival Ships Do Well
Shorter cruises and lower fares
Carnival uses most of its older ships for 3- to 6-night cruises. That makes them a low-cost way to try cruising or squeeze in a long weekend. Fares on the oldest ships are usually lower than on the newest ships sailing similar routes, partly because demand for the newest ships is so high.
Drive-to home ports
Older ships are spread across smaller and regional ports such as Jacksonville, Tampa and Norfolk, as well as busy hubs like Galveston. If you can drive to the port, you save on flights and a pre-cruise hotel, which can matter more to your total cost than the ship itself.
Refurbished, not tired
Three of the oldest ships, Sunshine, Sunrise and Radiance, were heavily rebuilt rather than just repainted. Their refits added many of the venues guests look for on newer ships, including Guy’s Burger Joint, BlueIguana Cantina, RedFrog Rum Bar, the Alchemy Bar and WaterWorks water slides. Elation and Paradise have also had regular dry dock updates. The age of the hull does not tell you how fresh the cabins and public rooms feel.
Smaller, easier ships
Elation and Paradise carry roughly 2,000 guests at double occupancy, against well over 5,000 on an Excel-class ship. Fewer passengers mean shorter walks, quicker embarkation, less hunting for a sun lounger and a more relaxed feel. Many cruisers who like a laid-back trip prefer this.
The trade-offs
Fewer dining options, and some newer concepts such as Emeril’s Bistro and Chibang! are only on the newest ships.
No headline attractions like the BOLT roller coaster.
Fewer balcony cabins, especially on the Fantasy-class ships.
Older layouts, with signs of age in some areas between refits.
Older ships are usually the first to be swapped to new ports or retired as new ships arrive, so long-term itineraries can change.
What the Newest Carnival Ships Add
The newest Carnival ships are the Excel class: Mardi Gras (2021), Carnival Celebration (2022) and Carnival Jubilee (2023). Each is around 180,000 gross tons and runs on LNG. What they add:
Zones such as Grand Central, Summer Landing and the Ultimate Playground, which spread people around the ship.
BOLT, the first roller coaster at sea, on all three ships.
More dining, including Emeril’s Bistro, Rudi’s Seagrill, Big Chicken and, on Celebration and Jubilee, Chibang!.
More balconies and new cabin types, including Excel suites and Loft 19 cabanas.
Newer tech and fewer age-related issues, along with lower emissions from LNG power.
The downsides are the flip side of the size: busier pool decks, more competition for shows and specialty dining, and generally higher fares, especially in the first few years after a ship launches. Excel-class ships mostly sail 7-night itineraries from Port Canaveral, Galveston and Miami, so they suit a week’s holiday more than a long weekend.
New Carnival ships on order
More newer ships are coming, which will gradually shift the fleet’s average age down:
Carnival Festivale: the fourth Excel-class ship, floated out at Meyer Werft in September 2026 and due to start sailing from Port Canaveral in May 2027. It debuts the Sunsation Point family area and the WaterWorks Ultra waterpark.
Carnival Tropicale: the fifth Excel-class ship, due in 2028 and set to sail from Galveston.
A new, larger class: three ships of nearly 230,000 gross tons ordered from Fincantieri, expected around 2029, 2031 and 2033. Dates and details may change.
Newer Carnival ships pack in bigger waterparks, more dining and headline attractions. Photo: Mathias Reding on Pexels
Carnival Old vs New Ships: Side-by-Side Comparison
Here is how older and newer Carnival ships generally compare. Individual ships vary, so check the details for your sailing.
Factor
Older ships (pre-2005)
Newest ships (Excel class)
Typical cruise length
3 to 6 nights, some longer
Mostly 7 nights
Typical fares
Lower
Higher, especially on newer launches
Guests (double occupancy)
About 2,000 to 3,000
About 5,000 or more
Home ports
Regional and drive-to ports plus major hubs
Major hubs such as Port Canaveral, Galveston and Miami
Dining choice
Core favourites, fewer specialty venues
Widest choice in the fleet
Headline attractions
Water slides, mini golf, SkyRide on some
BOLT roller coaster, larger waterparks, themed zones
Balcony cabins
Fewer, especially on Fantasy class
Many more
Crowds
Calmer and easier to get around
Busier, more planning needed
Condition
Depends on the last refit
Modern throughout
Are Newer Cruise Ships Better? Which to Choose by Traveller Type
Newer ships are better at some things, mainly variety, attractions and modern cabins, but they are not better for everyone. The right answer depends on what you want from the trip and how much you want to spend. We cover this question across all cruise lines in our guide to older cruise ships vs new ones; here is how it plays out on Carnival.
First-time cruisers: an older ship on a 3- to 5-night cruise is a cheap way to find out whether you like cruising. Sunshine, Sunrise or Radiance give you most of Carnival’s popular venues.
Families with teens and tweens: the Excel class, or Festivale when it arrives, is hard to beat for slides, BOLT and things to do on sea days.
Families with young children: either works. A smaller ship is easier to manage with toddlers, while newer ships have more splash areas.
Budget cruisers: older ships from a port you can drive to usually give the lowest total cost.
Couples and relaxed cruisers: older ships feel calmer, and itineraries such as the Carnival Journeys sailings and Spirit-class routes reach more varied ports.
Foodies: pick an Excel-class ship for the widest choice of specialty dining.
Cruisers who care about ship condition: look up the ship’s last dry dock date before booking. A recently refitted older ship can feel fresher than you expect.
One useful check most fleet lists skip: compare the per-night fare and the cost of getting to the port, not just the ship’s age. A 5-night cruise on Carnival Elation from a port you can drive to will often cost far less in total than a 7-night Excel-class cruise that needs flights and a hotel. If your main goal is time at sea and in port, the older ship can be the better deal. If the ship itself is the destination, go new.
Carnival Sunshine is the oldest. She entered service in 1996 as Carnival Destiny and was rebuilt and renamed in 2013. She sails from Norfolk until May 2027 and is due to move to Galveston in November 2027.
What ships has Carnival retired?
Recent departures include Carnival Fantasy, Carnival Inspiration, Carnival Imagination, Carnival Fascination, Carnival Sensation and Carnival Ecstasy, which left between 2020 and 2022. At the time of writing, no further retirements have been announced.
Is Carnival Elation older than Carnival Sunshine?
No. Carnival Elation entered service in 1998, two years after Sunshine (as Carnival Destiny) in 1996. Elation is the oldest ship that still has its original name and layout, which is why some lists call it the oldest.
What is the newest Carnival ship?
Carnival Jubilee, delivered in late 2023, is the newest Excel-class ship in service. Carnival Festivale is due in 2027 and Carnival Tropicale in 2028.
Are older Carnival ships cheaper?
Usually, yes. Older ships tend to sail shorter itineraries at lower fares. Prices vary by date and demand, so compare per-night fares for your dates.
The Star of the Seas cabins to avoid are mostly about location, not category. The usual trouble spots are Deck 14 rooms under the Chill Island pools, the Windjammer and The Hideaway. Next come cabins near the AquaDome, the casino and the Music Hall, and the Surfside-facing balconies if you aren’t travelling with young children. High forward cabins are worth skipping too if you get seasick. Choose a midship room on a deck with cabins above and below it, and Royal Caribbean’s newest Icon-class ship will give you a quiet night’s sleep.
Star of the Seas is the second Icon-class ship. It has 2,805 staterooms in 28 categories, and roughly 70% of them have a balcony. It sails 7-night Eastern and Western Caribbean itineraries round trip from Port Canaveral, and almost every one includes Perfect Day at CocoCay. With that many rooms and that many busy neighborhoods, the cabin you pick matters more than on a smaller ship. Below we go through the areas to avoid, area by area, and then look at the Star of the Seas best cabins for different kinds of traveler.
Star of the Seas cabins to avoid at a glance
The cabin numbers below come from the published deck plans. They’re approximate, so check the exact room on Royal Caribbean’s deck plan before you pay a deposit.
Area
Where
Main issue
Who should avoid it
Under Chill Island
Deck 14 midship (about 14172–14276 and 14572–14676)
Pool chairs moved early, music, deck games overhead
Light sleepers, late risers
Under the Windjammer and The Hideaway
Deck 14 aft-midship (about 14278–14362 and 14678–14752)
Breakfast rush, DJ and live music at the adults-only pool
Anyone who naps or sleeps in
Near the AquaDome
Deck 14 forward (about 14138–14170 and 14538–14570)
Rehearsals, events, foot traffic to Hooked and the AquaDome Market
Light sleepers
Surfside-facing balconies
Inward-facing aft rooms, decks 7–12
Splash pad, carousel-area noise, little privacy
Couples and adults without kids
Obstructed Central Park balconies
Deck 10 above The Pearl (about 10219–10235)
The Pearl’s roof blocks part of the view
Anyone paying extra for the park view
Near the casino and Music Hall
Lower decks 3–4
Late-night noise and crowds
Early sleepers
High forward cabins
Upper decks, bow
More pitching in rough seas
People prone to seasickness
Noisy staterooms below the pool and buffet decks
Under Chill Island
Chill Island fills the middle of Decks 15 to 17 with seven pools and a cluster of hot tubs, so it’s the busiest outdoor space on the ship. The Deck 14 cabins directly underneath can hear crew setting out loungers early in the morning, music through the day and the odd pool competition. Plenty of passengers never notice. If you’re a light sleeper, though, a cabin with more cabins above it is the safer bet.
Under the Windjammer and The Hideaway
Further aft on Deck 15 you’ll find the Windjammer buffet and The Hideaway, the adults-only area with an infinity pool, DJ sets and live music. The Deck 14 rooms below get the breakfast crowd and the afternoon party in turn. The Hideaway is a big draw for couples, but it’s much more enjoyable to visit than to sleep under.
Near the AquaDome
The AquaDome sits forward on Deck 15 and hosts aqua shows, daytime rehearsals and evening events. Hooked seafood restaurant, Rye & Bean coffee and the AquaDome Market are all close by. Deck 14 forward cabins near this complex can pick up vibration and hallway traffic.
Pool decks are great by day, but cabins directly below can hear them early. Photo: Jan van der Wolf on Pexels
Surfside and Central Park: neighborhood-view cabins
Surfside-facing balconies
Surfside is the family neighborhood at the back of Deck 7. It has the Splashaway Bay and Baby Bay aqua zones, the Water’s Edge pool, a carousel, a family buffet and an arcade. The inward-facing Surfside Family View Balcony rooms look straight down onto it from Deck 7 upwards. For parents of small children these rooms are a real advantage, because you can keep an eye on the area and you’re close to everything kids want. For couples or adults travelling alone they bring daytime noise, a view of other balconies and very little privacy. If you want to look at the sea, book an ocean-facing room instead.
Central Park rooms above The Pearl
Central Park on Deck 8 is open to the sky and is one of the quietest, prettiest spots on board, so most Central Park balconies are a good choice. The exception is a short run of rooms on Deck 10 sitting just above the top of The Pearl, the sculptural structure that also contains a staircase. The roofline there blocks part of the downward view. Book one of these only if you’ve seen exactly what’s outside the window.
Interior rooms facing inward
Some interior-category rooms have windows onto Surfside, Central Park or the Royal Promenade. Remember that people outside can see in as easily as you can see out. Keep the curtains drawn in the evening, and don’t expect the darkness of a true inside cabin.
Lower decks near late-night venues
Casino Royale is on Deck 4, and the two-level Music Hall sits nearby on Decks 3 and 4. Both get busy late, especially on sea days. The cabins sharing a corridor or wall with them aren’t a guaranteed problem, but if you’re in bed by 10pm it’s better to move a few frames further along the deck plan. On the plus side, Decks 3 and 4 are low, which helps with motion.
Cabins to skip if you get seasick
At around 250,800 gross tons, Star of the Seas is a very stable ship. Even so, the higher and further forward you are, the more any pitching can be felt. If motion is a worry, choose a cabin low and midship, roughly Decks 6 to 9 near the central elevators. That includes the forward-facing Panoramic Ocean View rooms and suites up front. They have dramatic windows, but they’re the first rooms to feel any swell.
Layout quirks worth knowing before you book
Sofa-bed rooms. Many balcony and family rooms sleep three or four by using a sofa bed in the living area. When it’s made up at night, the walkway between the beds and the balcony can become very tight. If four adults are sharing, a Family Infinite Ocean View Balcony or two connecting rooms will feel far less cramped.
Infinite balconies are not step-out balconies. In Infinite rooms, the window wall drops down to bring the “balcony” into the cabin’s footprint. You get more indoor space, but you don’t get a separate outdoor terrace to sit on while someone sleeps. Some Infinite Grand Suites work the same way, so check before paying suite prices.
Guarantee fares. A guarantee (GTY) booking is cheaper, but Royal Caribbean chooses the room nearer departure. That could be any of the spots above. If there’s a particular area you want to avoid, choose your own stateroom.
An ocean-facing balcony away from busy decks is the safest all-round choice. Photo: Cristina Silvestre on Pexels
Star of the Seas best cabins to book
The same deck plan that shows you what to avoid also points to some excellent rooms. Here’s how the main Star of the Seas staterooms compare, using Royal Caribbean’s published sizes.
Stateroom
Approx. size
Sleeps
Best for
Ocean View Balcony (Decks 7–14)
204 sq ft + 50 sq ft balcony
Up to 4
Couples who want fresh air and a sea view
Family Infinite Ocean View Balcony
335 sq ft
6
Families with two or three kids
Surfside Family Suite
269 sq ft
2 adults, 2 kids
Young families wanting Sky-tier suite perks
Sky Junior Suite
322 sq ft
4
Couples wanting a step up
Ultimate Family Townhouse
1,772 sq ft over three levels
8
Multigenerational groups with a large budget
Best balcony room for most people
For couples, a standard Star of the Seas balcony room facing the ocean and placed midship on Decks 8 to 12 is hard to beat. It has cabins above and below and is close to the elevators without being next to them. You’ll be away from the pool deck and Surfside and comfortable in rough weather. Central Park balconies away from The Pearl are a quieter alternative if a garden view appeals.
Family Infinite Ocean View Balcony
This room sleeps six. It has a separate bunk alcove for the kids and a split bathroom, so the shower and toilet can be used at the same time, and that makes busy mornings much easier. For families who don’t want a suite, it’s one of the most practical rooms on the ship.
Surfside Family Suite
This suite is around 269 sq ft and has a curtained kids’ nook with a sofa bed. It comes with Royal Suite Class Sky-tier perks, including suite dining and lounge access, and it’s right next to Surfside. That closeness is a drawback for couples but just what parents of under-sixes want.
Ultimate Family Townhouse
The Townhouse sits aft above Surfside. It spreads across three levels with three bathrooms, an in-suite slide and views over the wake. It’s the ship’s showpiece family room, and prices for a week often run into tens of thousands of dollars. For most people it’s something to admire rather than book.
A five-minute deck plan check before you pay
This is the step most guides skip. Once you’ve found a room you like, open the official deck plan and check three things:
Above: Look at the deck directly above your cabin number. You want more cabins, not a pool, buffet, theater or crew service area.
Below: Do the same for the deck below. Galleys, lounges and the casino can send noise upward.
Beside: Avoid rooms next to elevator banks, laundry rooms and service doors, which are often marked with small grey blocks. A cabin three or four doors away is usually just as convenient and much quieter.
What is the best deck to stay on Star of the Seas?
For most guests, Decks 8 to 12 midship are the best mix of quiet and convenience. They have cabins above and below, and the elevators are easy to reach. If you’re prone to seasickness, go lower and stay near the middle of the ship.
Are Surfside cabins on Star of the Seas noisy?
They can be during the day, because they overlook a splash pad, pool and family dining area. They’re excellent for families with young kids but not ideal for couples who want peace or privacy.
Should I avoid Deck 14 on Star of the Seas?
Not all of it, but the Deck 14 cabins directly under Chill Island, the Windjammer, The Hideaway and the AquaDome are the most likely to hear activity overhead. Look at what sits above your exact cabin number on the deck plan.
Is a guarantee cabin worth it on Star of the Seas?
Only if you’re relaxed about location. A guarantee fare saves money, but Royal Caribbean assigns the room, so you could end up under a pool deck or overlooking Surfside.
Carnival cruise fans are a passionate bunch. And they’re often fiercely loyal to the brand. But that doesn’t mean they don’t also like to have the occasional moan about how the cruise line has changed over the years.
And there have been some big changes.
Some are specific to Carnival while others are part of the shifting landscape of cruising in general, as every cruise line tries to be more environmentally-friendly, a little more budget-conscious, and perhaps even a little less controversial?
That’s definitely the case with some of these Carnival changes…
1. The Midnight Extravaganza
The Midnight Extravaganza was Carnival’s buffet blow-out, held just after midnight.
Picture walls of crab legs, mountains of carved ice, chocolate fountains and flaming Baked Alaska – all laid out in an over-the-top display four times the size of the regular buffet.
Actually, you don’t need to imagine it. Take a look at this video from the Carnival Celebration in 2007…
Many applaud the cleaner decks and quieter nights; others (particularly the snack-obsessed and social-media crowd) still hanker for that midnight feast under the stars.
2. The Quest
Ah, The Quest.
For the uninitiated, the best way to describe The Quest was as a scavenger hunt – but with a bit of a raunchy twist.
There wasn’t a set rule list for this team-based challenge that would take place on the cruise. It would depend on your cruise director as to how cheeky the game would end up.
But typically, it was a contest where guests had to seek out all manner of items, including bras or men’s shirts – and this would often lead to some chaotic scenes and probably a few flashed nipples that people would regret the next morning.
There would sometimes be a family-friendly version held too, I should clarify.
Officially, The Quest is gone for good. You might get some variants of it on a cruise, depending on your cruise director. But it’s not the same.
And that’s probably for the best.
3. Hairy-Chest & Belly-Flop Competitions
These were once regular fixtures on sea days – a bit of silly fun by the pool that saw brave (or overly confident) men line up to show off their chest hair or make the biggest, loudest splash in a flop contest. There were cheers, groans and usually a lot of sunburned stomachs.
But as Carnival began steering its image towards something a bit more family-friendly, the competitions started fading from the schedule. The hairy chest contest, in particular, was probably on borrowed time – even fans might admit it was starting to feel a bit outdated.
Still, these events had their fans. For some, they were part of Carnival’s cheeky charm – the kind of nonsense that made the cruise memorable.
And in fairness, you don’t easily forget the sight of those dudes proudly strutting their stuff in front of hundreds of poolside spectators.
4. Skeet-Shooting & Golf-Ball Driving
Believe it or not, you used to be able to do clay pigeon shooting on Carnival cruises. Passengers would line up on an upper deck, aim a shotgun over the sea (loaded with biodegradable pellets), and try their luck at hitting a flying target. Some ships also offered golf ball driving into the ocean.
These days, you’d be hard-pressed to find anything like that on board. The environmental concerns alone would be enough to sink the idea, and it’s hard to imagine a modern Carnival ship handing out firearms – even if they were controlled and supervised.
There’s no real outrage about their disappearance, though a few long-time cruisers miss the novelty of it. But in truth, these were niche offerings – interesting to try once, but not exactly the cornerstone of the Carnival experience.
Once upon a time, your cabin steward would visit not just once a day, but twice – making your bed in the morning and returning in the evening to turn it down, leave chocolates on the pillows and reset the room for the night.
These days, unless you’re in a suite, you’ll only get one visit per day – part of Carnival’s shift to streamline operations and reduce strain on housekeeping staff. It also happens to be better for the environment, with less laundry and water usage.
Most guests have accepted the change without much fuss, but that second visit did add a little something extra. There’s just something nice about coming back to a freshly fluffed bed and a mint, especially after a long evening show or late dinner.
6. Onboard Videographers
In the pre-smartphone era, Carnival had onboard videographers filming everything from sailaways to poolside games and formal nights. They’d then edit it into a souvenir video, which you could purchase at the end of the cruise.
It was never cheap, and it was never subtle. I’m told that the camera crews had a knack for appearing right when you were red-faced and half-drenched after a bellyflop contest, or trying to dance when you absolutely should not have been.
Eventually, as passengers started documenting their own holidays with phones and GoPros, the onboard video team quietly disappeared.
These days, you make your own memories – for better or worse. And while some might miss the polished, ship-produced recap, most people are probably happy not to have a camera following them around every deck.
7. Printed Carnival Capers and Menus
Carnival Capers – the daily printed newsletter – was once the lifeblood of the cruise. Slipped under your door each night, it laid out every event, activity and show happening the next day, plus the weather forecast, dress code and a few bits of cruise director humour.
Alongside it, you’d also get printed menus in the dining room, which you could read at your leisure or even take as a souvenir.
Eventually, these all moved to the Carnival Hub app. It’s efficient, saves paper, and lets the cruise line make real-time updates – handy when something’s cancelled or moved.
But it’s not quite the same as sitting on your balcony in the morning, coffee in hand, flicking through a physical copy of everything going on that day. You can still request the (now rebranded) Fun Times as a paper copy, and you can get paper menus if you ask – but a lot of people just feel like it’s inconvenient.
Menus especially felt like keepsakes – people would take them home, fold them into scrapbooks, or use them to remember their favourite dishes. Now it’s all on a screen, and while it works just fine, it doesn’t have the same charm.
8. Topless Sunbathing Deck
For a while, Carnival allowed topless sunbathing in designated adults-only areas on some of its ships. These decks were usually tucked away in quiet corners and not widely promoted, but they existed – and some guests made full use of them.
Over time, those spaces were phased out. They were never hugely popular, and there were ongoing issues with signage, guests wandering in by accident, and a general sense of awkwardness for staff who had to enforce the rules.
These days, it’s swimsuits on for everyone, everywhere. Not many people even noticed the change, but there’s a small group of loyal naturists who still bring it up from time to time – usually with a nostalgic shrug and a sigh about “how cruising used to be.”
Carnival’s pizza has always had a bit of a cult following – hot, fresh, thin-crust slices served from the poolside pizzeria. And for years, it was available 24 hours a day. Whether you’d just come back from a late-night comedy show or were heading out for a sunrise walk, pizza was always there.
But not anymore. The hours have been scaled back, mostly to give the staff a break and cut down on late-night food waste. It still runs most of the day and well into the evening, but if you’re looking for a 3 am pepperoni fix, you’ll probably be out of luck.
A late night snack menu has been added to the buffet, but it’s not the same – choices are limited and the pizza isn’t the same quality you can enjoy elsewhere on the ship during daytime hours.
A shame – and something people are still unhappy over.
10. Bluetooth Speakers Permitted
There was a time when guests could bring Bluetooth speakers on board and use them freely – on balconies, in cabins, and even on deck.
It didn’t take long for that to become a problem. Competing playlists at the pool, thumping bass at 7 am from the balcony next door, and impromptu parties that no one else signed up for.
Carnival eventually stepped in and banned them completely. It was one of those rare changes that almost everyone welcomed. Peace returned to the pool deck, and now the only music you hear comes from the ship’s own sound system.
Some people still ask why they can’t play their music in private, but the blanket ban avoids any grey areas. And really, no one’s ever missed someone else’s speaker blaring EDM at sunrise.
11. Free Popcorn at Dive-in Movies
Dive-In Movies – the open-air films shown on deck under the stars – are still going strong. What’s missing now is the free popcorn that used to come with them. For years, Carnival would hand out small tubs of popcorn at no charge, and it added a proper cinema feel to the experience.
That’s all stopped now. These days, if you want popcorn, you’ll have to buy. It’s a small change, but noticeable for anyone who remembers the old days.
Some say it’s no big loss – after all, it’s still a free movie with a sea breeze. And apparently it’s stopped some issues with people taking the freebie and then just throwing it around the pool deck.
But there’s something undeniably satisfying about munching popcorn under the stars, and without it, the Dive-In Movie nights just feel a bit more… ordinary.
12. Tablecloths in the Main Dining Room
There was a time when dinner in the main dining room meant crisp white tablecloths, neatly folded napkins, and a more traditional, formal dining experience – even on casual nights. It gave meals a little extra sense of occasion, whether you were tucking into lobster tail or just ordering a burger with fries.
Carnival started phasing them out years ago. These days, most dining rooms have bare tables with simple place settings. It’s more relaxed, easier to clean, and cuts down on laundry – all sensible reasons.
Still, some guests miss that touch of elegance. Tablecloths made dinner feel like a proper event. Without them, it’s still enjoyable – but there’s no denying it feels just a little more like a busy restaurant than a special night out.
13. Trays in the Buffet
Buffets on cruise ships used to have trays – the big kind you’d balance on your arm, stacking up plates, bowls, drinks, and maybe even dessert if you were confident. Carnival removed them to reduce spills, ease traffic flow, and discourage guests from piling up more food than they could eat.
It’s a change that’s mostly stuck. Today, you’ll grab a plate or two and make more trips if you’re hungry.
And while that’s probably a good thing, there are people who say they found it easier to carry a tray, some old-school cruisers still bring it up, especially when juggling plates during peak lunch rush. But for most, it’s just the new normal.
14. Free Room Service
For years, room service on Carnival was completely free, available day and night. You could order sandwiches, desserts, hot meals, even breakfast trays delivered to your cabin – all without paying a penny (though tipping the delivery staff was always encouraged).
That’s changed. Room service now comes with a charge for most items, especially during evening hours. A few light bites remain complimentary during the day, but the full menu is behind a price tag.
Understandably, this one still stings for a lot of guests. There’s something deeply satisfying about eating a grilled cheese in your pyjamas while watching the waves go by. People will still use the service, but that sense of indulgent luxury – the feeling that you could order just because you could – has definitely faded.
15. Special Menu Items
Carnival used to offer a wider range of special menu items that would pop up on certain nights – whether it was a regional dish inspired by the ship’s itinerary, a themed dessert night, or an over-the-top presentation like Baked Alaska parades. These items were often a surprise and gave meals a bit of extra excitement.
But over time, the menus have been simplified. Fewer one-off dishes, fewer theatrics, and a more standardised experience across the fleet. It helps things run more smoothly in the galley and keeps waste down – especially as dining rooms got busier.
That said, people still talk about the “old menus.” The Elegant Night lobster tails. The escargot. The crew marching in with flaming desserts. Those touches might not have been essential, but they were memorable – and the current dining options, while solid, don’t always spark the same level of enthusiasm.
16. Pepsi Products
Carnival used to be a Coca-Cola cruise line – you could get all your familiar Coke products onboard, from Diet Coke to Sprite to the occasional exotic Fanta flavour.
But that changed when Carnival made the switch to Pepsi, a change that rolled out across the fleet in early 2020.
And for something as small as a soft drink, it stirred up a surprising amount of emotion. Some people genuinely didn’t mind, or even preferred Pepsi. But others… didn’t take it quite so well.
But then they got some good news in the summer of 2025 as the cruise line announced it was returning to Coca-Cola products.
So great news for Coca-Cola fans, but the people who prefer Pepsi are now the ones missing out.
17. Personalised Service
One of the things long-time Carnival fans talk about is how personal things used to feel. Cabin stewards and bartenders would remember your name, your drink order, even how you took your coffee in the morning.
You didn’t have to ask twice – they just knew.
As the cruise line got bigger and the ships more crowded, some of those little touches started to fade. Service is still friendly, but it’s more streamlined now – less time to chat, more focus on efficiency. For newer cruisers, it’s still impressive. But if you’ve sailed Carnival for years, you’ll probably notice the difference.
It’s not that the crew don’t care – far from it. They’re working just as hard as ever. But with more guests and fewer repeat interactions, that feeling of being known and recognised throughout the ship isn’t as common as it once was. And for some people, that’s the thing they miss the most.
NEW DEALS JUST RELEASED!
See the latest Carnival cruise offers…
Final Word
Cruising with Carnival has never stood still. Over the years, the cruise line has evolved – trimming back, streamlining, and modernising its experience in ways that make sense from a business, environmental, or logistical perspective.
Some of these changes have been welcomed with open arms (goodbye, Bluetooth speaker battles), while others still spark the occasional nostalgic rant on cruise message boards.
What’s clear is that Carnival has tried to strike a balance between keeping things fun and moving with the times. But for long-time cruisers, the small touches that used to define the experience – the turndown, the midnight crab legs, the cheeky bellyflop contests – still hold a special place in their memories.
So if you find yourself grumbling about missing chocolate on your pillow or scanning the buffet for a tray that isn’t there, you’re not alone. And who knows? Maybe some of these lost favourites will find their way back in one form or another.
Related Posts
If you found this interesting, please share!
Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.
Ever wondered how lucrative it would be to work on a cruise ship?
Can you make a decent living, or do you sacrifice that for the benefit of a job that may not pay well, but lets you travel and see the world?
One crew member from Royal Caribbean has revealed all by sharing his payslip – and you might be surprised.
Chris Wong Shared His Payslips With Us
Chris Wong is a British crew worker who joined Royal Caribbean in 2013, starting out in the gift shops before finding his niche in the casino.
Away from the tables he runs @ChristopherWongVLOGS, one of the most-watched cruise-life channels on YouTube, with 114,000 subscribers.
And in one of his most popular videos, titled “How Much Money I Currently Earn Working On A Cruise Ship in 2025”, he announced that his current contract will be his last – but not before revealing exactly what a month in the job paid.
Crew Pay Revealed
Royal Caribbean pays its crew every two weeks, and Chris shared that in January 2025 he received two payments.
Pay Period
Net Pay (USD)
Net Pay (GBP)
First half of January
$2,890.21
£2,145.52
Second half of January
$1,450.09
£1,076.50
Monthly total:
$4,340.30
£3,222.93
What’s important to remember is that this salary doesn’t take into account Chris’ lifestyle as a crew worker, and what he doesn’t have to pay for.
Because he’s working on a cruise ship, he enjoys:
Free accommodation
No utility bills, except optional internet expenses
Free food
“That’s a lot of money, especially when you’re not paying rent or car payments… It’s actually pretty difficult to earn that kind of salary back in the UK right now.”
Chris, in his video
Why the Numbers Change
A casino host’s income is made up of:
Base salary – fixed each month.
Commission – a percentage of casino revenue, usually higher on larger, North-American-based ships.
Guest tips – often added to a player’s account or handed over in cash at the tables.
When Chris worked as an assistant host on the Caribbean-based Icon of the Seas, a bumper month of tips pushed his earnings close to US $5,000 – more than he currently makes in a more senior role on a smaller ship sailing from Australia.
In other words, where the ship sails and who the guests are can matter as much as your job title.
How Gratuities Work on Royal Caribbean
Many crew rely on tips to make up part of their salary, and those on Royal Caribbean are no different.
Guests on Royal Caribbean see an automatic service gratuity added to their SeaPass account unless they choose to pre-pay before sailing:
US $18.50 per person, per day in standard cabins
US $21.00 per person, per day in suites
Those amounts are pooled and divided among hundreds of “front-of-house” crew – stateroom attendants, dining-room waiters, assistant waiters and head waiters.
Back-of-house teams (galley, laundry, provisions) are paid fixed wages, while revenue-generating departments such as the casino rely on a mix of salary, commissions and discretionary tips.
Because the pot is shared, removing the automatic charge at Guest Services – something the cruise line allows, but discourages – reduces the entire pool and everyone’s share, not just the service you happened to be unhappy with.
Seasoned cruisers who prefer to hand over cash tips still tend to leave the automatic amount in place, then reward individuals on top.
Where Extra Cash Tips Make the Biggest Impact
Stateroom attendant – the person who turns your cabin around twice a day.
Dining-room wait team – especially on longer voyages where they get to know your preferences.
Bar staff – drinks carry an 18 per cent service charge, but an extra dollar or two per round goes straight to the server.
Casino staff – dealers and hosts are usually excluded from the main gratuity pool, so consider tipping directly if you enjoy their service.
Because casino staff aren’t generally included in automatic gratuities (although it varies by cruise line), typically anything you pay as a cash tip in the casino will be pooled and shared equally amongst the casino staff.
That way, all crew members in the casino get to share in some form of tipping pool even if they aren’t the ones dealing the winning hands to the guests (when they are often at their most generous).
Chris Wong’s Next Chapter
After eleven contracts Chris is handing the casino-host baton to a colleague and “sailing into the next phase” of his life.
He has not yet said whether dry land or another cruise line is in his future, but with a healthy savings pot, a thriving YouTube channel and a decade of stories to tell, his options are wide open.
His example shows that ship life offers more than sunsets and buffet dinners; it can provide a solid income with minimal overheads if you are willing to work hard, live in close quarters and keep smiling when the passenger at the roulette wheel asks for five more red chips.
Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.
Guests aboard Disney Wish experienced a frightening evening on Tuesday 26th August 2025, when the ship’s “man overboard” alarm sounded shortly after leaving Nassau.
Rescue operations were quickly launched, but it has since been confirmed that the alarm was a false report.
Alarm and Rescue Efforts
The Wish-class flagship departed Nassau at 5:30 pm and was en route to Disney’s private island, Castaway Cay, when the overboard alert was made just before 8 pm.
Cruise ship tracking data showed the vessel turning back and stopping roughly 15 miles north of Nassau.
As part of standard emergency protocol, crew members deployed life rings and launched rescue boats while powerful spotlights scanned the water.
Guests onboard reported seeing the search in progress, with at least two rescue craft deployed to investigate.
To ensure passenger safety, all travellers were called to their muster stations for a full headcount.
False Alarm Confirmed
By late evening, Disney Cruise Line confirmed that the incident was a false alarm.
The object initially thought to be a person in the water was actually a large piece of debris.
After a full passenger and crew count, everyone was confirmed safe and accounted for.
The ship then resumed its journey towards Castaway Cay, where it arrived on schedule on Wednesday morning.
Heightened Awareness After Recent Incident
This incident comes just two months after a genuine overboard case aboard Disney Dream on 29th June, when a child fell into the sea and her father jumped in after her.
Both were rescued successfully by the ship’s crew.
While false alarms can be disruptive, they also demonstrate the effectiveness of cruise safety systems.
Any possible overboard sighting triggers an immediate response involving search operations, life-saving equipment, and passenger verification to rule out any missing persons.
Disney Wish is currently sailing a 4-night Bahamas itinerary that departed Port Canaveral on 25th August, with Nassau and Castaway Cay as its two ports of call.
NEW DEALS JUST RELEASED!
Don’t miss the latest Disney Cruise Line offers…
Related Posts
If you found this interesting, please share!
Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.
A family holiday aboard Norwegian Getaway turned into tragedy when a father drowned at Bermuda’s Horseshoe Bay – and now his relatives are taking Norwegian Cruise Line to court. The…
Royal Caribbean’s ambitious new private destination, Perfect Day Mexico, has run into controversy as residents and activists raise concerns about the development’s potential impact on Costa Maya. A Change.org petition…
Guests aboard Carnival Panorama endured a frightening moment on Wednesday evening when the ship unexpectedly listed after running into a severe storm in the Gulf of California. The 4,008-passenger ship…
A family’s recent cruise could have ended in tragedy after a young child was photographed standing on a table dangerously close to the edge of their private balcony. The image…
Let’s get started with another full of the latest cruise news from Cruise Hive, including guests getting frustrated over public announcements, two cruise airlifts from Ruby Princess, a petition pushing back against Royal Caribbean’s plans for Costa Maya, and Wonder of the Seas begins sailings from Miami.
Cruise Hive was founded in 2008 by Emrys Thakkar, a former crew member and someone who has a massive passion for cruise ships. He has grown Cruise Hive into what it is today, a leading independent publisher covering the latest cruise news, advice, and more!
Everyone is talking about Royal Caribbean’s new ship that just launched – but what they’re not talking too much about is how expensive cruises on this new ship are!
For an almost-identical cruise, Royal Caribbean is charging more than double what MSC Cruises is charging for its newest ship.
But here’s the big question: is Star of the Seas actually twice as good… or are you just paying for the hype?
I’ve compared the prices, what’s included, the onboard facilities and the overall experience to help you decide which cruise gives you the best value for your money.
I totally get why people are excited to cruise on the newest and biggest ship in the world. After all, that’s exactly what I did when I booked my very first cruise!
I chose Allure of the Seas for my honeymoon in 2013. Why? Well all I did was search Google for ‘best cruise ship’ and as that was the newest and biggest at the time, that’s what came up!
But savvy cruisers will know to do a bit more research than I did when I booked the new Royal Caribbean ship without looking any further.
Would you be better off having TWO cruises on MSC’s newest ship, and have money left over for souvenirs?
Let’s find out in this head-to-head between Royal Caribbean’s Star of the Seas and MSC World America.
Star of the Seas Vs MSC World America
First, let’s start by taking a look at some key stats…
Star of the Seas
MSC World America
Launch date
August 2025
April 2025
Size (gross tons)
250,800
215,863
Decks
19
22
Guests (max)
7,600
6,774
Crew
2,350
2,138
There’s no denying that Star of the Seas is huge. But World America is pretty big too.
Sure, booking a cruise on Star will give you the bragging rights to say you’ve been on the biggest ship in the world. But aside from that, you won’t actually notice the size difference once you’re on board, as they’re both so gigantic that it will take you a week to find your way around.
Key Features Of These Ships
Both Star of the Seas and MSC World America have a lot of fun activities on board. These aren’t cruises for people who’s idea of relaxation is sitting on a sunlounger all day!
Waterparks
Star of the Seas features the largest waterpark at sea with six record-breaking slides, seven swimming pools and ten whirlpools.
Star of the Seas waterpark
World America also has an elaborate waterpark with four slides. Guests can also enjoy six pools and 14 whirlpools.
MSC World America Waterslides
Thrills
Thrill seekers on Star of the Seas can get their adrenaline fix on Crown’s Edge – a skywalk meets obstacle course adventure int the ship’s Thrill Island neighbourhood. There’s also a FlowRider surf simulator, mini golf, laser tag and rock climbing walls.
Crown’s Edge on Star of the Seas
There are also plenty of thrills to be had onboard MSC World America, which features the only over-water swing ride at sea, Cliffhanger. There’s also a dry slide called Jaw Drop, which will take you down 11 decks, as well as bumper cars and a sports arena.
Cliffhanger on MSC World America
Entertainment
Star of the Seas features the awe-inspiring AquaTheatre where daring divers leap from 60 feet above, Absolute Zero which has shows on ice as well as the AquaDome with incredible aerial performances. In the theatre you can see Broadway-style shows like Back To The Future The Musical and there’s also a dedicated comedy club as well as endless live music venues.
AquaDome on Star of the Seas
Oh, and did I mention that Star of the Seas has a dog that lives onboard? Sailor is a Golden Retriever who’s role is to bring joy to the guests!
The entertainment doesn’t seem to be quite as extensive on MSC Cruises’ new ship. But there is, of course, a theatre, a 4D cinema and live music throughout the ship.
World Theatre on MSC World America
Food and Drink
Star of the Seas features more than 20 different restaurants and 25 bars – which is way more than you could visit in a single cruise! There’s a huge range of complimentary dining options, as well as speciality restaurants that are available for an extra charge.
MSC World America has 13 dining venues and 18 bars, which is still plenty! There are enough complimentary options, but for something other than the main dining room, buffet or snacks, you’ll need to pay extra.
What Costs Extra?
Both Royal Caribbean and MSC Cruises charge extra for certain things, so most cruisers pay more than the ticket price.
The standard inclusions are the same with both cruise lines – accommodation, meals, entertainment, port fees and taxes. But it’s worth considering how much you can expect to pay for things like gratuities, drinks and wifi once onboard.
I’ve broken down the extra costs into a table for you…
Star of the Seas
MSC World America
Gratuities
$18.50 per person, per day
$16 per person, per day
Drink Package
$56 to $115 per person, per day
$85 per person, per day
Wi-Fi
Around $25 per device, per day
Around $112 per device, per week
Attractions
$90 for Crown’s Edge
$5 for Cliffhanger
Speciality Dining
$25 to $200 per meal
$25 to $55 per meal
An extra $2.50 for gratuities might not sound like a lot – but for a family of four over a week, that works out at an extra $70 you’ll be expected to pay out to subsidise the crew members’ wages.
When it comes to the drink package, Royal Caribbean is notoriously secretive about their prices. The package prices are fluid and vary depending on your sailing date and when you book it.
At the highest price point, it’s virtually impossible to break even versus buying your drinks individually, but if you can bag a deal after booking (look out for 30% off discounts in the Royal Caribbean app) then the pricing may be comparable to, or even cheaper than, MSC Cruises’s drink packages.
Wifi is another added extra that has fluid pricing with Royal Caribbean. If you want wifi on your cruise, you can expect to pay similar prices with each cruise line.
However, I would also definitely recommend that you look into getting an e-SIM as an alternative. I like to use GigSky which usually saves me a lot of money and the wifi is just as good, if not better, than the official ship wifi.
Get 10% OFF GigSky eSIMs
Enter code CRUISEMUMMY10 at checkout to get this discount
When it comes to activities, MSC Cruises charges extra for several of the attractions onboard World America. The prices are pretty reasonable though, and honestly, I would rather pay a nominal fee than have to queue for hours.
You can see the prices in the flyer below…
On Star of the Seas, the only attraction that has an extra fee is the Crown’s Edge. That’s the hight ropes course that goes over the side of the ship. This costs a whopping $90, which honestly, would put me off doing it.
You can sometimes get discounts that make it only $50, but still, it’s pretty pricey for a few minutes of fun when there’s so much that you can do on the ship for free.
Speciality dining is priced pretty similarly across the two ships, with lunches starting at $25. However, Star of the Seas does have some more premium options, with Chef’s Table, which costs $110 per person and the Lincoln Park Supper Club, which costs an eye-watering $200.
Lincoln Park Supper Club on Star of the Seas
You can also arrange a meal the Celebration Table private dining experience for up to 14 guests at a cost of $1,000.
The speciality dining is pretty reasonable onboard MSC World America, with the price capped at $55 per meal. You can also get packages for 2 meals for $99, 3 meals for $139 or 4 meals for $179.
However, I do think that Star has some better free options. For example, El Loco Fresh is a Mexican restaurant that’s included in your fare, whereas the Mexican option, HOLA! Tacos & Cantina costs extra on MSC Cruises.
Itineraries
Star of the Seas sails out of Port Canaveral. This is a great option as it means you can combine your cruise with a visit to Florida’s theme parks. British cruisers will find plenty of flights to here from London and Manchester.
MSC World America, meanwhile, departs from Miami. If you’re in the UK, that will mean paying more for your flights, or making the journey down from Orlando, which isn’t ideal.
Now, let’s take a look at the ports of call for these two cruises…
Both cruises call at San Juan and have a couple of sea days. They each both have a stop at private resorts that are owned by the cruise line.
For Royal Caribbean, that’s Labadee in Haiti, whereas for MSC Cruises that’s Ocean Cay Marine Reserve. You can read my guide to the best cruise line private resorts to see how the two compare. I’m not saying that one is ‘better’ than the other, but Labadee has more to do, with a zipline and roller coaster, whereas Ocean Cay is made for chilling.
Ocean Cay MSC Marine Reserve
And finally, Star of the Seas will visit St Thomas in the US Virgin Islands, while World America will visit Puerto Plata in the Dominican Republic. Both of these are great options – St Thomas is fantastic for shopping, while Puerto Plata has a historic charm and great beaches.
Value For Money Verdict
If you want the full experience of a floating theme park, Star of the Seas delivers in dramatic fashion. The multiple ‘neighborhood’ zones are cleverly planned, the entertainment is off the scale and the food is incredible, no matter your taste.
While Royal Caribbean’s newest ships are undeniably expensive, when you compare it to the likes of Disney Cruise Line, it suddenly looks much more mid-range.
MSC World America, on the other hand, leans into value. The finish is a little less polished, the food isn’t quite as tasty, and the service may be a little slower and less friendly. you’d prefer to cruise twice (or save half your cash), it’s a solid option.
When choosing between these two mega ships, your budget is sure to play a part. If you want the best, then you can’t deny that Royal Caribbean is better. But is it twice as good? Honestly, I’m not sure it is.
TODAY’S BEST CRUISE DEALS!
Don’t miss these offers…
Related Posts:
If you found this interesting, please share!
Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.
A photo of a child dangerously close to a cruise balcony railing have gone viral. 8500 people were adrift at sea in the MSC World Europa. Locals are challenging Royal Caribbean’s Perfect Day Mexico and Carnival is returning to Acapulco for the first time in 10 years. It’s everything going on in cruising. Join this […]
Cruising, as an industry, has evolved a lot over the last 20 years or so. And while there are a ton of newer cruise fans, there are probably just as many who’ve cruised for a long time – and they aren’t always happy with the changes that have been made.
Royal Caribbean has long been one of the biggest cruise lines in the world, but it’s a very different proposition to the cruise line that won over previous generations of fans.
So I did some digging, and put together a comprehensive list of the things that Royal Caribbean used to offer, that they no longer do.
And yeah – it’s not a short list. I can’t believe there are over 50 things on it!
First though, check out this commercial from the 1980s!
Cabin Service & Amenities Changes
1. Twice-a-day housekeeping no longer offered
2. Turndown service with chocolates is long-gone
3. Towel animals are not necessarily provided
4. Fruit baskets no longer given to all staterooms
5. The Cruise Compass is now fully digital – no more printed options
6. No stationery provided in your cabin
7. Toiletries have gone from branded items you could take home to generic dispensers
8. Bathrobes are no longer automatically provided
9. Mini-bar restocking isn’t consistent
There was a time when staying in a Royal Caribbean cabin felt like a treat in itself. But over the years, many of the small touches that added charm and comfort have quietly disappeared.
For example, twice-a-day housekeeping is no longer the norm. These days, guests are asked to choose whether they’d like their cabin cleaned in the morning or evening – not both.
Along with this, the classic turndown service with chocolates on your pillow is now a thing of the past.
Towel animals, once a nightly delight, are now hit-or-miss. Some guests still get them, but many don’t.
Fruit baskets, once a welcome gift in all cabins, are gone too unless you’re in a suite. You’ll also notice that printed Cruise Compasses – the daily schedule – are no longer automatically delivered. You’ll need to use the app, or ask at Guest Services if you prefer a paper version.
Other niceties have faded as well. Cabin stationery, like note paper and postcards, is no longer provided. Toiletries have changed too – branded mini bottles have been replaced with wall-mounted dispensers.
Bathrobes are no longer automatically provided in most cabins, and even mini-bars may not be restocked unless you specifically ask.
While none of these changes are deal-breakers on their own, together they reflect a shift away from the pampering experience many cruisers remember. These little touches made your cabin feel special – now, things are simpler, and a bit more stripped-back.
Buffet Changes
10. The Midnight Buffet has been discontinued…
11. As has the Chocolate Buffet (typically)
12. You don’t get ice sculptures and special décor in the buffet anymore
13. Speciality sushi offerings in the buffet are not common
Royal Caribbean’s buffets used to be events in their own right – something passengers genuinely looked forward to. But over time, many of the stand-out features have quietly disappeared.
Most noticeably, the midnight buffet, once a nightly highlight with elaborate spreads and creative displays, is no longer offered. This was more than just a late-night snack – it was a bit of theatre, complete with ice sculptures and decorative themes. Today, it’s been replaced by more basic grab-and-go options.
Also missing is the chocolate buffet, which used to delight guests with everything from chocolate fountains to themed desserts. While chocolate treats can still be found onboard, the dedicated buffet has largely been phased out.
Likewise, speciality items like sushi, once included in the Windjammer buffet under the Jade brand, are now more likely to be found in extra-charge venues like Izumi.
Gone too is the sense of occasion. Buffets now tend to favour function over flair, with fewer themed decorations or standout dishes.
It’s all still clean and efficient, and there’s certainly plenty to eat, but the wow factor has been scaled back. Many guests miss the fun and excitement these buffets used to bring – it wasn’t just about filling your plate, but enjoying a spectacle.
These changes may be part of Royal Caribbean’s effort to reduce food waste and streamline service, but for long-time cruisers, it feels like something joyful has quietly slipped away.
16. The popular cold soup dishes (e.g. chilled fruit soups) are gone
17. Lobster tails are now more limited
18. Fewer courses – you used to see appetizers, soups and salads as distinct courses
19. No more dessert cart to show off the various options
20. Special chateaubriand nights are no more
21. Themed nights with décor have stopped
Dining in the main restaurant used to be a highlight of the cruise – something many guests dressed up for and genuinely looked forward to each evening.
But over the years, several long-standing traditions and favourites have quietly disappeared from the experience.
Perhaps the most iconic loss is the Baked Alaska parade. Once a flamboyant end to the cruise, waiters would march through the dining room with flaming desserts held high, often to cheers and applause.
Today, it’s gone (and it’s gone from most other cruise lines, too) along with other tableside flambé dishes, like Cherries Jubilee or Bananas Foster, which were once a real treat to watch and enjoy.
Cold soups, like fruit-based chilled options, have mostly disappeared from menus. These unique starters were a refreshing change and a fan favourite for many.
Similarly, lobster tails, once a regular highlight of formal nights, are now usually limited to one complimentary portion – with extra tails coming at a cost.
There’s also been a clear simplification in how meals are served. Guests used to receive separate courses for appetisers, soups, and salads, making meals feel more elegant.
Today, these are often merged or reduced. The dessert cart, where staff would show off your choices in person, has also vanished – now you simply order from the menu.
Other traditions, like themed dining room décor on special nights and Chateaubriand nights, have been quietly dropped.
While dining is still enjoyable, many guests miss the flair, variety, and sense of occasion that the main dining room used to offer every evening.
Dress Changes
The formal night dress code is no longer strictly enforced
22. You can’t rent a tuxedo onboard anymore
23. Formal nights used to be a big part of the cruise experience, especially on Royal Caribbean
Guests would don their finest eveningwear – tuxedos, cocktail dresses, even floor-length gowns – and the whole ship would take on a more glamorous feel. These nights felt special, like stepping into a black-tie event at sea.
While you’re still welcome to dress up, it’s no longer expected. You’ll now see a mix of outfits in the dining room on formal night, including people in polo shirts, casual dresses, or even shorts.
For some, this makes things more convenient, especially when packing, but others feel it takes away from the sense of occasion.
Another tradition that’s disappeared is the onboard tuxedo rental service. For those who didn’t want to pack formalwear, renting a tuxedo used to be an easy option.
It was especially helpful for first-time cruisers who wanted to take part in the tradition without committing to buying a full outfit. Now, with rentals gone and dress codes more relaxed, many cruisers simply skip the formality altogether.
While the more casual approach appeals to some, especially families or those on shorter cruises, others miss the elegance and shared experience of a ship-wide formal evening. It’s one of several examples of Royal Caribbean shifting towards a more laid-back, flexible cruise style – at the expense of old-school cruise charm.
Bar & Beverage Changes
24. You can’t enjoy free sodas in the Main Dining Room anymore
25. Souvenir glasses aren’t typically made of glass
26. You can’t drink any duty-free that you buy onboard
27. More restrictions on the alcohol you can bring onboard
28. You used to get free champagne at farewell dinners – but no more
There was a time when drinks on a Royal Caribbean cruise felt like a bit more of a treat – both in terms of price and experience. But over the years, several changes have reshaped how drinks are served, what’s included, and how much you’ll pay for them.
Did you know that sodas used to be included at no extra charge when you were in the Main Dining Room? Where soft drinks were once included as part of your meal, they’re now only available through a paid soda package or individually at extra cost. This change alone has surprised many returning cruisers.
Souvenir glasses – especially those tied to cocktails of the day – used to be made of actual glass and often felt like a keepsake worth bringing home. Today, they’re more likely to be plastic (if offered at all), and many guests feel the quality has dropped.
There are also stricter rules around alcohol. You can no longer drink any duty-free liquor bought onboard during your cruise – it’s held until the end.
Similarly, bringing your own alcohol onboard is now far more restricted than it once was.
And finally, one charming touch that’s gone is the farewell dinner champagne toast.
Where once two bottles of bubbly might be placed on each table as a celebratory send-off, this gesture has disappeared. These little moments added a sense of occasion – now they’re just fond memories for longtime cruisers.
Entertainment & Activity Changes
29. The DreamWorks character experiences have been discontinued
30. Horse racing games have been taken away
31. Skeet shooting and golf ball driving activities have been removed
32. Rarely see overnight stays at islands
33. No more live bands by the poolside
34. Passenger talent shows have been phased out for generic karaoke
35. Crew entertainment during dinner has been mostly removed
Entertainment used to be one of the most memorable parts of a Royal Caribbean cruise – and while there’s still plenty to do, some beloved traditions and unique activities have quietly disappeared over time.
One big loss is the DreamWorks Experience, which brought characters like Shrek and the Madagascar crew onboard for meet-and-greets, themed events, and kids’ activities.
It was a highlight for many families and a big reason some guests chose Royal Caribbean over other lines. Today, it’s gone, replaced with more generalised youth programming.
Horse racing games, once a fun and interactive pastime, have also disappeared from most ships. So too have more unusual activities like skeet shooting and golf ball driving off the back of the ship, which were once part of the “only at sea” charm.
While safety and environmental concerns played a part, these offerings were unique and helped set cruising apart from a land-based holiday.
Island overnights, where you could stay docked overnight and explore more deeply, are now extremely rare with the cruise line.
And the vibe around the pool deck has shifted too – live bands have become less frequent, replaced by DJs or, more commonly, pre-recorded music playlists. It’s a change not all guests appreciate.
Other touches – like passenger talent shows, crew performances during dinner, and a general sense of ship-wide celebration – have been phased out.
Many of these were small, informal traditions, but together they helped make cruising feel fun, social, and a little bit magical. Their absence leaves some regulars feeling like the spark just isn’t quite the same.
Venue Changes
26. The Sky Pad virtual reality trampoline is gone
37. Cigar Lounges have been mostly eliminated
38. You don’t get a proper chapel on newer ships
39. Libraries have been downsized or removed
40. The Viking Crown Lounge has been repurposed
41. Onboard flower shop services have been removed
As Royal Caribbean updates and modernises its ships, a number of familiar venues have been quietly removed, repurposed, or scaled back – sometimes without much fanfare.
For long-time cruisers, this has meant the disappearance of some favourite spaces that once added personality and variety to the onboard experience.
One of the most noticeable changes is the removal of the Sky Pad on the Freedom Class ships, a virtual reality trampoline attraction that was popular with both kids and adults.
While the structure may still be visible, the activity itself has been discontinued.
Similarly, cigar lounges like the Connoisseur Club have been phased out, leaving smokers with fewer – and less comfortable – places to unwind.
More subtle, but just as disappointing for some, is the loss of dedicated chapel spaces. These quiet venues were used for weddings or vow renewals, but also for regular religious services, and their absence on newer ships removes an option many guests valued.
Libraries, too, are either gone or drastically downsized, as the cruise line leans into digital entertainment.
The Viking Crown Lounge, once a signature space with sweeping views and a relaxed vibe, has been repurposed on newer ships – often for suite guests or speciality venues. While replacements may offer modern flair, many feel they lack the charm and accessibility of the original.
And finally, even the onboard flower shop, which allowed guests to buy fresh arrangements for celebrations or surprises, has disappeared.
It’s one of those little touches that, while not essential, added warmth and a little bit of a romantic vibe to the cruising experience.
Loyalty & Perk Changes
42. Concierge Lounge Access for Diamond Plus members is typically gone
43. Printed keepsakes including passenger lists have been taken away
Royal Caribbean’s Crown & Anchor Society has long been a key part of the cruise experience for repeat guests, rewarding loyalty with special perks, access, and little surprises.
But over the years, some of those benefits have been reduced, restructured, or removed.
One of the most noticeable changes is the removal of Concierge Lounge access for Diamond Plus members.
This used to be a popular perk that gave high-tier guests access to a quiet, exclusive space for drinks, snacks, and service. Now, it’s the Suite Lounge, and generally reserved for suite guests only.
Printed keepsakes, like passenger lists or commemorative cruise documents, were once a charming way to remember your trip. These have been phased out, likely in the name of cost and efficiency.
While the Royal Caribbean app offers a digital experience, it doesn’t replace the feeling of holding a thoughtful souvenir in your hand.
Having said that, a printed passenger sounds a bit sus… I think GDPR might have an issue with it today!
Guests have also noted that small gifts, priority boarding, and exclusive discounts have been quietly downgraded or removed altogether for lower-tier members. Even some mid-tier perks don’t feel as generous as they once did.
In general, the loyalty programme has shifted away from adding value for repeat cruisers and towards upselling more premium options, like suite bookings and paid experiences.
While the points still add up, many seasoned travellers feel the returns aren’t quite what they used to be – and that the line is more focused on new bookings than rewarding those who keep coming back.
General Service Changes
44. You aren’t greeted by crew as you board and shown where your cabin is
45. Galley tours are now more limited
46. Bridge tours have generally been discontinued for security reasons
50. The cruise line is moving away from that small-ship atmosphere
51. More limited towel service poolside
52. Free popcorn at movie nights is no more
53. Room service is now charged
54. Exercise classes cost extra
55. Birthday and anniversary cakes are an extra charge
56. No more streamers launched off the ship at sail away
Beyond specific venues or perks, some of the most noticeable changes on Royal Caribbean cruises have been to the overall service and onboard experience.
In the past, it was common to be greeted by crew as you boarded, with someone even escorting you to your cabin.
That personal touch has disappeared, which you can understand for the modern megaships – that’s a lot of crew needed to greet 6,000+ people!
The once-standard streamers tossed off the ship at sail away are gone – a celebratory tradition many fondly recall. It probably wasn’t the best for the environment, though.
Bridge visits have largely been phased out, and galley tours are more limited, often due to security or health regulations, but it’s still a noticeable loss for those who enjoyed seeing behind the scenes.
You also can’t invite non-cruising guests onboard before sailing, which was once a fun way to share the experience. Even the tender ticket system has gone, replaced by a less structured, first-come-first-served approach that can cause confusion.
Paper has also been pushed aside. Cruise documents, passenger lists, and even daily planners like the Cruise Compass are now largely digital, which isn’t always a smooth transition – especially for older passengers.
Elsewhere, once-standard touches like poolside towel service, free popcorn at movie nights, and celebration cakes for birthdays or anniversaries now often come with a charge.
You can still swap towels near the pool, but it might be a more hidden away space. The popcorn is more likely to be a charged extra now. And the cakes? Also available to buy if you want.
As one guest put it though, that’s not necessarily a bad thing…
But add in things like paid room service, extra charges for fitness classes, and a shift towards larger ships that feel less personal, and it’s easy to see why some loyal cruisers say the magic has faded just a bit.
The core of the cruise is still there – but many of the extras that made it feel special have quietly sailed away.
NEW DEALS JUST RELEASED!
Don’t miss the latest Royal Caribbean offers…
Final Word
Cruising with Royal Caribbean is still a great way to relax, explore, and enjoy life at sea – but it’s hard to ignore how much the experience has changed over the years. Many of the little extras that once made a cruise feel luxurious, charming, or just plain fun have slowly disappeared.
From the loss of turndown chocolates and midnight buffets to the scaling back of loyalty perks and onboard traditions, these changes may seem minor individually, but together they signal a shift in what cruising looks and feels like today.
But hey, it’s not all doom and gloom. Far from it. Ships are bigger, more high-tech, and packed with new activities.
It’s important to remember what’s been added as well as what’s been taken away!
Whether it’s cost-cutting, modernisation, or changing passenger expectations, one thing is clear: the Royal Caribbean experience is evolving. It’s not quite what it used to be – but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. I’d rather have a zipline than skeet shooting anyway!
Related Posts
If you found this interesting, please share!
Jenni Fielding is the founder of Cruise Mummy. She has worked in the cruise industry since 2015 and has taken over 30 cruises. Now, she helps over 1 million people per month to plan their perfect cruise holidays.